Published - Sunday, March 14, 1999
Birth rights: Woman's search for her parents
leads to a pivotal role in worldwide
organization that champions adult adoptees
By DEBBIE BLOSSOM
SUN Staff Writer
There was a time when Pat Marler
couldn't even say the word "bastard."
Today, however, it slips easily into her
conversations, and she even has a T-shirt that
is printed with a logo and the phrase "Bastard
Nation."
And the Edmond resident isn't afraid to wear
it.
Marler is a member of an organized group of
adult adoptees who are fighting for their
identities - people who want nothing more than
the right to the official documents that say
who they are and where they came from.
A fight, she says, that may take a long time to
win.
In most states, outdated laws that seal
adoption records leave adult adoptees without
legal access to birth certificates when they
turn 21, unless they can persuade a judge to
open those records.
But Marler and a growing number of adults
across this country and the world want the same
rights as anyone else. They want to know who
their birth parents are, even if they aren't
planning to contact them.
They want to uncover their historical and
genetic identity, especially any medical
information that could make a difference in
their health and the health of their families.
"None of this is about children - it's about
adults," she said.
As Oklahoma's vocal contact for Bastard Nation,
Marler makes it a point to know what the laws
are in other states and what legislation might
be pending.
She spends at least two hours a day answering
e-mail from
others wanting to know which way to turn as
they search for records and birth parents. She
has publicly rallied for a change in Oklahoma
and supported adoptees in other states as their
laws have been challenged, revised and
contested.
"That's what we are working for here," Marler
said. "That's what we're all about."
----
When Marler was born in 1945, pregnancy outside
of marriage and adoption itself was shrouded in
secrecy and a stigma that has eased a
generation later.
Initially, she said, sealed records and
confidentiality was intended to protect
adoptive parents and children from disapproval
from a community, but those standards simply
don't apply in a changing world.
Instead, sealed records now protect birth
parents who believe their rights and promises
of privacy will be invaded if their children
obtain their birth certificates.
And Marler is exasperated with lawyers,
legislators and adoption agencies who continue
to refer to all adoptees as children whose
rights are less important than those of the
parents.
"Birth parents get more rights than adopted
adults," she said.
And that's just not fair, she added. "There is
no law giving parents total anonymity for the
rest of their lives."
Marler said she is lucky. She found her birth
mother with the assistance of members of a
support group she attended and a searcher who
found her documents but couldn't reveal the
contents.
"Someone else looks up your records," she said,
unhappily referring to the state of Iowa's
confidential intermediary system that is
similar to Oklahoma's. "Everyone looks through
your records but you ... it's like you can't
take care of your own private life."
But the end result was positive, and Marler
recalls nervously calling the mother she never
knew.
"I contacted her and she was excited ... her
first words were, 'What took you so long?'"
Through her birth mother, she quickly located
her father, who was ill at the time. Although
he didn't want to establish a relationship, he
did fill Marler in on the various forms of
cancer on his side of the family.
It was an impersonal encounter over the
telephone, but she finally had the medical
background she needed for herself and her two
sons. "It doesn't just affect me, but everyone
down the line.
"I'm disappointed he didn't want to meet me,
but that is his right to not have a
relationship with me," she said.
But like most adult adoptees, Marler wondered
about her birth parents.
"I just wanted to know who they were ... you
always wonder, 'Who do I look like?' It
completed what I needed to have in my life."
----
Marler's search for her birth parents took less
than a year, but "I had been thinking about it
for 48 years," she said.
Yet it still took four more years of endless
phone calls and wading through bureaucratic red
tape to finally get her original birth
certificate released and into her hands in
Oklahoma.
"It was my determination," she said, that
finally led her to a judge in the county where
she was born who unsealed her past. "He knew
there was no reason not to."
Bastard Nation's goal is for every state to
have laws like those in place in Kansas, where
every adoptee who is 21 or older can legally
obtain a birth certificate.
"Kansas is totally open, and always has been,"
Marler said. "Hopefully, someday it will happen
here."
There is also unconditional access in Alaska,
but there are stipulations to the law in
Montana. Last year, voters in Oregon passed an
initiative, Ballot Measure 58, that allowed for
open records. But that move is now being
challenged as well as new legislation in
Tennessee.
This session, legislators in Texas are
considering replacing a 1973 law that sealed
records, and Marler said she is keeping her eye
on Oklahoma's neighbor to the south.
In January 1998, Oklahoma approved a mutual
consent registry that allows adult adoptees to
sign up, at the cost of about $400, for a
search that usually concentrates on locating a
birth mother.
If found, the birth mother can choose not to
release the name of the father or any
information, she said.
"It's not a fair process, and it puts another
governmental process on an adopted person who
doesn't need it."
She doesn't support the program although she
does tell people who contact her about it.
There are other national registries that help
adoptees search, and their services are free.
----
When it comes to change, Oklahoma is behind the
times, Marler said.
"Oklahoma is a sleeping state" she maintains.
There is no legislation pending with lawmakers
and few people are active in the campaign for
adult adoptees' rights.
As one small voice in a sea of opposition, she
knows that alone she can't change the world.
"As one person, I don't think I have too much
clout," she said.
So her goal is to make more people aware of and
involved with Bastard Nation, even adoptees who
don't have a desire to contact their birth
parents.
She hopes to forever dispel the notion that the
word "bastard" means something bad. "I've
learned to say it and I can be proud of it."
"I'm making this something positive ... working
for adoptive people's rights. You can legislate
laws, but you can't legislate biology.
"You're different than your adoptive parents
... you don't have the same genes."
Yet out-of-date thinking prevails, she said,
and once someone is adopted, those genetic ties
are broken - forever.
"How do you do that?" she said. "Realistically,
you can't."
|